The beatings will continue until morale improves

The Federal government has been active in primary and secondary education since 1954, with good reasons, first to foster equality; then to pursue excellence. The equality part worked, as the formerly smarter segments of the population have become dumber, although I doubt dumbing down was a goal. Excellence, however, has been elusive, despite massive increases in funding & planning. Education is an Obama priority, as it has been for every president. Why can’t they get it right?

Maybe this has failed not in spite of all the effort but because of it. Standards are not being met, so we impose tougher and more comprehensive standards. When they don't work, we get tougher.

Back in 1983 the President's National Commission on Excellence in Education published a report called, "A Nation at Risk." It was pretty scary stuff and is called a landmark in educational reform. Since that time we redoubled our efforts and redoubled them again. Thirty years and billions of dollars later things are worse.

Maybe maybe less effort would produce more result than more effort.

Think of how gasoline works in a cylinder. A small amount of gasoline produces a big bang. Adding two or three times as much produces smaller results and if you flood the engine with gasoline it doesn't work at all. Perhaps our best efforts are the problem, not the solution.

We have subjected our whole education system to the bureaucratic imperative that identifies problems, makes rules to fix them and then "holds people accountable" for results. This sounds really good and may be good when there is a simple and well defined problem. But as the rules and procedures accrete, the goal is often lost. Sometimes you can't find a pony in the pile of manure.

I recall a joke (I think it was a joke) among the Marines that the response to low morale was to say "the beatings will continue until morale improves." Maybe we should lighten up on the Federal rules, accept some disorder and some ostensible sub-optimization so that we can make real progress.

Posted by Christine & John at August 18, 2013 8:31 AM
Comments
Comment #369517

There is another common thread running through many years of our education failures…unions.

Posted by: Royal Flush at August 18, 2013 10:46 AM
Comment #369521

Royal

IMO, public employees who work for the people and enjoy a variety of civil service protections should not have unions with collective bargaining ability. This would be especially true for teachers, who have the responsibility to teach our kids. Teaching is their task. Protecting poor performers, as unions often do, is immoral in this context.

Presumably, teachers would have professional associations with the goal of improving the quality of instruction and sharing best practices. They are professionals, after all, not assembly line workers.

I fear union leader sometimes lose sight of their mission, which is to improve the profession of teaching and not protecting particular teachers.

Posted by: CJ at August 18, 2013 12:46 PM
Comment #369532

While the stats do look bad there are some valid reasons why US education seems lacking. For one, note that the US is comprised of several ethnic groups with widely varying socio-economic conditions. Whereas, Japan, Finland, the top contenders have relatively small populations and are largely of singular ethnicity. I would suggest the top contenders socio-economic condition relates fairly close to our upper middle class folks.

http://www.cbpp.org/cms/?fa=view&id=1258

Throwing wads of money at education in such a diverse population just doesn’t get you the bang for the buck.

http://www.edudemic.com/2013/07/how-12-countries-spend-education-money-and-if-it-makes-a-difference/


http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/11/27/best-education-in-the-wor_n_2199795.html

Highly social, highly developed countries are keenly aware of the value of an education and will pursue that objective way more aggressively than competing countries.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/in-s-korea-the-best-education-means-a-sacrifice-for-parents/2012/11/05/6adb0564-256f-11e2-9313-3c7f59038d93_story.html

A big, big reason you don’t get the bang for the buck is that teacher standards are significantly different from the top contenders to the lesser ranked nations. If one were to place several top teachers in Singapore in a big city US school I suggest you would get a big bump in achievement for those kids. What with the unions, traditions and cultures it’s kind of like the blind leading the blind in some school systems, IMO. And, that’s a hard, hard thing to change.

Posted by: Roy Ellis at August 18, 2013 8:43 PM
Comment #370603


Champions League last season in the limelight was the Bundesliga [microblogging] Hutch seize; said transfer market purchasing power,franklin marshall clothing uk the French giants rallying cry rival? As Barcelona [microblogging] Real Madrid [microblogging], is always the focus,superdry factory outlet which is planning to poach money in the Premier League last season by taking four awards - Bell [microblogging]. Well, the world’s strongest leagues attract the biggest selling point is what? Only one answer: Jose Mourinho!
After a lapse of six years, his CV has increased by eight trophies at Inter [microblogging], the two European giants Real Madrid coaching experience honed birds Uncle corners.ralph lauren sale uk At least, he should also know how to get along with Abu. Chelsea [microblogging] [microblogging] but also because of his arrival to become the number one favorites. And Moyes,lacoste polo australia compared Pellegrini, Mourinho advantages: familiarity. Know more about the league than his team locker room with only one person - Wenger, but the Blues squad strength and thickness of the players but let gunmen have a “sense of distance.” Terry, Michael Essien and Frank Lampard is no longer young, it is difficult to ensure that the starting position, how to create a new axis? Enough to form two luxury lineup in the frontcourt, how to mix is ??the strongest? His mouth, “the last and only” wait Rooney [microblogging] If you can not come, the main striker in Demba Ba or Torres? Mourinho is the best at solving the problem of modern football coach,abercrombie fitch outlet the Premier League era, with his most exciting!
Moyes got a dream job, but also accept the most challenging tasks: the continuation of “post-Ferguson era” Red Devils dynasty brilliant. Ferguson at Manchester United [microblogging] [microblogging] final home game last season after touching speeches still wanders over at Old Trafford, watching his leave of glorious achievements, he sincerely hopes fans force very next coach. This requirement in the new season schedule out after even more important, the former Manchester United at home against Crystal Palace 5 in addition to outside the rest is immune to win four games to grasp. In case after five scores worse than expected, predictable pressure from all sides, we can maintain the magic secret given enough patience to understand? From the data, nearly 11 Premiership season are “who in the world was at home,” home record decide the fate of the title race. Ferguson’s experience, judgment and prestige no one can replace, in the “Dream Theater” Moyes could have enough appeal?
Individual expects to face Manchester United after the coaching change there may be more trouble appeared on the road, while a draw at home and avoiding too much to appear.ralph lauren sale Despite the preseason Community Shield on the stability of the smooth crowned morale helpful, but they want to remain competitive, leaving Wayne Rooney is still the key. Introduction of Tiago and small law fails, see the Red Devils midfield signings idea is to enhance creativity, Rooney is the best partner for Robin van Persie is the best once the Dutchman missing injured striker candidate. Forget that the transfer farce it, please remember: Families with Lu chubby, Fortune Happy Life!
“Engineer” Pellegrini Villarreal and Malaga in the past [microblogging] started their places, pre-season he has lofty claim that Manchester City [microblogging] [microblogging] has Premiership strongest lineup.ralph lauren outlet uk Indeed, the paper strength of Blue Moon’s three lines more evenly, in front attack point distribution more reasonable. The problem is that there is pressure to win Pellegrini, Real Madrid dressing room complex is not successful, it returned to the stranger got Premiership he can manage it? Warm-up match in Helsinki team lost 1-3 Arsenal [microblogging], showing smashed one hundred million pounds of new lineup or the lack cohesion, the lack of core, can have two and Yaya - Toure as stable star What? Manchester City last season lost “Champion desire,” it can get it back? Chileans not only do the work of engineers, but also bear the “inspirational guru” of the task.
Arsenal did not put into the ranks of the title race, a lot of gun enthusiasts certainly very disappointed. Particularly throughout the summer to become the object of ridicule, taste upset. But the reality is so cruel, riding a boat behind. As Gunners legend Winterburn said, to really return to the team title race group,Ed hardy uk not only Suarez, but also at least two additional reinforcements. How to win half of the season did not lag behind, get rid of the last two quarters in February after habitual downturn, do not rely on the last two months of the season sprint? Relative to the break of eight years without a crown “curse”, to keep the top four ranked still is the primary goal.

Posted by: tooo21212 at September 13, 2013 4:29 AM
Post a comment